Advertisement
i'm taking this class about writing narrative for film, and the mythologies behind the 'hero's journey', which makes large references to jung's work and joseph campbell's work.. i approached the prof after the last class to mention that i felt the narratives being presented and discussed were uniquely male, which is an appropriate reflection of mainstream media, but why was he not making an effort to present more diverse narratives?
he was initially defensive, thinking i was criticizing him, which i wasn't, he's a great prof... but once we got over that he suggested that i make a lecture presentation as my class project. he said he would be willing to let me have a class to show a film of my choice and talk about it....
i'm kind of intimidated by this prospect, not sure if i should feel flattered or resent having the responsibility passed off to me, and trying to work out suitable ideas for a presentation.
i was thinking of showing a film by catherine breillat, perhaps 'romance' or 'the anatomy of hell'. and discuss narrative from a woman's perspective.
i'd be curious to hear any thoughts about this at all... do you think it is too severe, that i'll just scare people, or that it is a good reflection of feminine psychology?.......
anyway, i'm nervous about the idea and any feedback would be helpful.
he was initially defensive, thinking i was criticizing him, which i wasn't, he's a great prof... but once we got over that he suggested that i make a lecture presentation as my class project. he said he would be willing to let me have a class to show a film of my choice and talk about it....
i'm kind of intimidated by this prospect, not sure if i should feel flattered or resent having the responsibility passed off to me, and trying to work out suitable ideas for a presentation.
i was thinking of showing a film by catherine breillat, perhaps 'romance' or 'the anatomy of hell'. and discuss narrative from a woman's perspective.
i'd be curious to hear any thoughts about this at all... do you think it is too severe, that i'll just scare people, or that it is a good reflection of feminine psychology?.......
anyway, i'm nervous about the idea and any feedback would be helpful.
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Unsu...
Re: the anatomy of hell...
Wed, September 26, 2007 - 3:02 PMIt's a great idea if you feel you're up to it. It's smell steps like this that are really helpful. Plus it's educating for the rest of the class, their gain as well as yours. -
-
Unsu...
Re: the anatomy of hell...
Wed, September 26, 2007 - 4:27 PM"smell steps"? ha! A minor typo there, that was supposed to be "small steps".
-
-
Re: the anatomy of hell...
Wed, September 26, 2007 - 6:05 PMthis sounds like an awesome project! seriously, enjoy yourself and run with it.
if you're at all nervous about presenting materials that is beyond too many other students' heads, i'm thinking that maybe _a jury of her peers_ would be a suitable alternative. if nothing else, it would provide an easy way to illustrate different male and female ways of knowing and telling. and from my experience, you can couple that with some more theoretically complex readings, for instance some cixous, to productive ends.
in any case, best of luck with your presentation!
-
Re: the anatomy of hell...
Wed, September 26, 2007 - 8:51 PMI really like Catherine Breillat's work but she is undoubtedly a very challenging film-maker. I can see how 'Romance' would fit into the course's theme (albeit in a dark, rather satiric way) but I wonder if '36 Fillette' might not be a more accessible but equally relevant film.
Whatever you choose, I think it's fantastic that you spoke up and that you took this project on. Good luck!
-
Re: the anatomy of hell...
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 4:33 AMCloé - I'd highly recommend Women Who Run With the Wolves by Clarissa Pinkola Estés. It's probably not specifically relevant for your film class since it's about myths and old stories but it is a great read vis a vis women's storytelling and myths of the wild woman (and the heroine's journey :-) Absolutely brilliant book - kind of like a Joseph Campbell but for the ladies - every woman should read it at least once :-)
-
Re: the anatomy of hell...
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 7:58 AMCloé - Well, I'd suspect that you may scare some people but perhaps that's a good thing ;-) In some senses, I'm serious. Simply because things that have a big emotional impact usually get people talking and asking questions. I would, however, perhaps contextualize her work. And perhaps even offer some examples of other female directors whose perspective is a bit less experimental and confrontational (unless all the films by men being screened are also experimental and confrontational). I suggest this mainly because there's a tendency to ghettoize feminist and female artists - or to locate them in an exclusive space and under *a* theory - and it can be useful to illustrate the diversity of women's perspectives. We too, amongst ourselves as women, are different but equal :-) From my perspective anyway!